12 janvier 2012

Jim Budd's Declaration of assistance

This morning, my dear colleague and friend Jim Budd published his "declaration of assistance' on his blog. It's HERE for all to see.

This sort of financial coming-out was apparently urged by a certain Warren Edwardes who seems to think we owe it to the readers.

I disagree. And here is my plea.

Dear Jim, I don't think I will ever make such a declaration, unless under a new nazi regime ;-)

Who needs to know how difficult it is for us to make a living out of wine journalism?

And why should one free train ticket or hotel room change the way I feel or write about the wines I taste? People invite me because they want to know what I really think (I hope).
You can declare what you want, Jim, and I am sure that you will do it accurately and honestly, but the demand by Mr Edwarde seems irrelevant to me.

Will you declare also your sexual preferences, your clothing preferences, your cooking preferences? Watch out - it could explain a lot in the way you review the wines you taste!

And what about the choices you don't make? When an editor sends you to one region instead of another one, do you know how much advertising his or her magazine gets for it? You see, to comply with Mr Edwarde's demand makes you look like you are responsible for everything when you are not.
 
Anyway, I suppose Latin people like me really don't feel the same way re these petty matters. We live in an imperfect world, and only our conscience can vouch for our behaviour. Or is it the other way round?

I guess I should think it over a little more - wish I had the time, because it is a important topic, but I have a familly to feed. Things to write in order to get paid.

Sorry if I spoke out of turn, it just had to get out, because I am fed up with this general "cleaner than thou" attitude in our so-called modern society (makes me think of Hoover-times in the US of A).

And I feel that willy nilly you give the Mr Clean-guys ammo when you don't have to. Might even become a rule one day; like having my little Cotton dog on a leash here, on the streets (new rule this year in Waterloo, Belgium), as if it were a Rottweiler. Till last year, rules only said the owner was responsible for his/her dog, that was of the essence - responsibility, not the means you use to prevent your dog from doing any harm or damage, just the responsibilty.

Likewise, I feel responsible for what I write, accountable for it, but I don't think my expenses can prove anything.

What about trust? Who said we were all potential offenders?

And don't get me wrong, Jim, I have nothing more to hide than you do.

Grr, I knew it was going to be a bad day, today, and my tooth aches.

 

12:34 Écrit par Hervé Lalau dans Vins de tous pays | Lien permanent | Commentaires (1) | | | |

J'ai essayé... Littineraires Viniques

Je ne connais pas personnellement M. Bétourné, aussi quand j'ai lu son commentaire, début 2011, à propos de l'infâme billet que j'avais osé écrire à propos des blogs de vins (rappelez-vous, le Post Incorrect), je n'ai pas vraiment "percuté", comme on dit dans l'Armée.

Ce n'est qu'aujourd'hui que je comprends vraiment à quoi il fait référence. Je parlais des blogs "abscons". Il l'a pris pour lui et pour lui seul. Il avait tort. Parce qu'à l'époque, je ne connaissais pas assez son blog, Littineraires Viniques. Je n'en avais lu qu'un petit extrait. Pas assez pour se faire une idée juste.

Depuis, j'ai réparé cette lacune. Maintenant, je sais.

blog de vin

 

Autant vous l'avouer, M. Bétourné, je ne suis pas vraiment fan de ce que vous faites. Disons que ce n'est pas ma tasse de thé. Comme Milos Forman fait dire à Salieri, je crois, à propos de Mozart, dans son Amadeus, "il y a trop de notes". Notez bien que Mozart est resté dans l'histoire, alors que Salieri...

Mais il y a plus important: je conçois que votre blog ait ses adeptes; et je ne vise pas à les décourager, d'autant que je vous crois sincère et surtout, passionné. Alors qui suis-je pour vous enlever votre passion, pour vous dire comment écrire et sur quel thème?

Moi, je n'aimerais pas qu'on me le fasse.

Je me répète, la grande force de la blogosphère, c'est sa diversité, il y a des lecteurs pour tous styles de prose et de poésie, et même, qui sait, certains de mes plus fidèles lecteurs, au contraire de moi, accrochent à votre style.

Tout ceci pour vous dire, M. Bétourné, de blogueur à blogueur, que je vous respecte, et je vous souhaite de continuer longtemps encore votre Littineraire...

00:09 Écrit par Hervé Lalau dans Vins de tous pays | Tags : blog de vin, littineraires viniques | Lien permanent | Commentaires (8) | | | |